Troubleshooting and optimization for drilling process

Troubleshooting and optimization for drilling process based on deflection and breakage of HSCO twist drills in use with multi spindle, Jigs and fixture on special drilling Machine

Amir Alinaghizadeh , Soheil Nazarpour , Behnam Davatgar

1-Faculty member of mechanical engineering department, Energy and Sustainable Development Research Center, Semnan Branch, Islamic Azad University, Semnan, Iran

1,2,3-Research and Development office, Technical and Engineering Department, Tabesh Abzar Pars Company, Tehran, Iran


Drilling is a cutting process which uses a twist drill bit to cut or enlarge a hole of circular cross-section in solid materials such as metals, polymers, etc. In this study, optimization of the cutting parameters on drill deflection and fractions was performed. The optimization of the cutting parameters was evaluated based on imperfection in Drilling tools and substantial tool life decreasing. The control parameters were considered as machine properties, cutting speed, feed rate, drill ratio lengths to diameters, workpiece material and other relevant parameters in order to detect malfunctional root causes.

All of the parameters were studied deeply in order to detect the root cause. All parameters as tool originality, tool material, machine properties, tool lengths, and all the possible parameters step by step and at the end root cause of problem had been detected in machine tool clutch system. All the parameters and study methods are explained in detail and step by step accordingly.


Drilling is one of the popular machining methods and is used in most assembly processes. Various aspects of drilling have been investigated, such as process modelling, tool material, cutting force, and surface roughness. The Aim of this case study is to Troubleshooting and optimization for drill machining based on deflection and fraction in HSCO drills in use with multi spindle, Jigs and fixture equipped special Machines in which tool life has been saliently decreased. All the technical explanations about this malfunction, studies and results will be explained accordingly in the next steps.

Problem Explanation, Innovations & Aims of Paper

As illustrated in Figure 1 there are six holes to be machined on each workpiece. Multi-spindle machine had been used in order to machine six holes in three steps (drilling, stepping drilling, and reaming operations)

Cutting tool specification and cutting conditions were used to drill 4 holes (10.00mm) and 2 holes (8.7 mm) in three stations (Figure 1) based on information in Table 1:

Troubleshooting and optimization for drilling process

Troubleshooting and optimization for drilling process

All the necessary parameters to discuss are categorized as below:

Troubleshooting and optimization for drilling process

Figure 1: Workpiece and holes machining points.

As already mentioned, normal tool life for drilling is 200 Pcs per each twist drill tool and the number had been decreased to 3 Pcs per tool after malfunction appears (Figure 2)

Troubleshooting and optimization for drilling process

Figure 2: Drilling tools deflection after three holes machining

In parallel another malfunction appeared in product line was drilling tool breakage inside workpiece which causes production line stoppage in order to rework the parts and detach fracted tool from workpiece. (Figure 3)

Troubleshooting and optimization for drilling process

Figure 3: Broken twist drill piece inside workpiece hole

Another important parameter which must be considered were exhaustion of production timeworn drill machine with following explanation:

Multi-spindle drilling machine with three rotational workstations and three-station fixtures and a jig plate with three jig bushes for operations such as drilling, step-drilling and reaming (Figure 4)

Troubleshooting and optimization for drilling process

Figure 4: Drilling machine in use

Research Method and Assumptions

Research method was considered based on TAP Tools company method and all the studies were based on mentioned method in accordance of machine’s structure and its operation conditions in production line. A summary of study will come in resumption:

Tools identity: First study was about originality of the tools and to check all the parameters in case if damaged tools have different origin.

Specifications checked as shown in Table 2:

Table 2: Tool identification information

Troubleshooting and optimization for drilling process

Tool material: material test on twist drills was performed by “Razi Applied Science Foundation” in order to check if there is any material difference between old and new tools in use and the result replied as below:

Chemical Analysis by Atomic Emission Spectrometry (OES)

Standard Test Method: ASTM A751 (2014a)/ ASTM E415(2017)

Standard Practice for Reporting: ASTM E1950 (2017)/ ASTM E29 (2013)

Instrument: HITACHI PRO.2

Preparation sample: Grinding

Material type: Ferrous

Result of chemical analysis test has been shown in Table 3. According to the result, chemical composition of the sample conforms to the designated requirement of DIN HS 6-5-2-5 (1.3243) as illustrated at Table 4.

Manufacturing Engineering

Optimization of external grooving operations with the defect elimination approach in the selection of machining strategy and parameters

Amir Alinaghizadeh , Armin Tabaghi , Mohammad Nemati

1- Faculty member of mechanical engineering department, Energy and Sustainable Development Research Center, Semnan Branch, Islamic Azad University, Semnan, Iran

1,2,3- Research and Development office, Technical and Engineering Department, Tabesh Abzar Pars Company, Tehran, Iran.


The machining process was affected by different factors. The proper adjusting of these parameters plays an important role especially in terms of workpiece quality. The grooving process is one of the most challenging operations in turning. This paper covers experimental tests in order to improve tool life in the grooving process. The optimization process was applied through adjusting cutting parameters - Cutting speed, Depth of cut and Feed rate per revolution) which were selected according to workpiece material and machining specification.

Besides that, machining strategy, regards to tool path, improved by using multiple-grooving method for roughing and a four-step technique for finishing process. Also, some hints were used to make machining conditions much better like pre-machining of oxidization layer (which was a result of workpiece material forging process) and changes in the cooling system. Test results have shown that the chosen strategy for grooving and other preparation can prevent insert breakage and led to improved tool life.


One of the most challenging machining operations on a lathe is grooving. The grooving term is referred to make a groove (usually narrow) with a certified depth [1]. Grooving has different applications such as Machining O-ring seating, V-belt pulley, make a slot for lubrication, and machining the end part of the threading portion. Nowadays, indexable grooving tools are widely used.

Different types of inserts are used to make a groove related to machining parameters (cutting velocity, depth of cut, feed rate). Generally, grooving inserts are not suitable to perform other turning processes like external turning, facing, turning…, but some of them have different applications. They are also called “MDT”[2] which is an abbreviation for Multi-Directional Turning that is applied for a variety of turning applications that usually have one or two cutting edges.

The important difference between external turning and external grooving is the cutting direction. External grooving is usually applied in the radial direction while in external turning operations, the cutting direction is parallel to the workpiece axis. According to that, usage of grooving inserts be limited and lower feed rate and depth of cut should be considered[2].

Problem Explanation, Innovations & Aims of Paper

Machining parameters that are not selected correctly, like cutting speed, depth of cut, feed rate, chip breaker, and tool material grade lead to poor tool life and insert breakage[1, 3]. Different type of chip breakers geometries is used related to machining condition (roughing or finishing). The most contributing factor for proper chip control in external grooving is the feed rate. Besides that, different shape of chip breakers is developed for a wide variety of materials[4]. For example, a chip breaker with beams is suitable for gummy materials[5]. (Fig. 1) 

Manufacturing Engineering

Fig. 1: Schematic view of chip breaker with beams[5]

Different strategies are applied through external grooving. However, most of them result in tool damage because of avoiding machining rules. To perform external grooving by roughing method, three common strategies were suggested [6]. First of all, in case the depth to width ratio is up to 1.5,

Fig. 2: Grooving strategy for roughing process regard to depth


Manufacturing Engineering

to width ratio a) up to 1.5[7] b) more than 1.5[2]


a grooving strategy is applied (Fig. 2a). Groove produce by radial movement of the tool, then return and feed in an axial direction and similar actions were performed again up to machining the desired width. In case a greater depth of cut was needed, this strategy applied in consequence passes. (Fig. 2b)

Secondly, in cases the depth to width ratio is more than 1.5, a multiple grooving strategy is applied. The desired width was produced by equal interval grooving and after that, the remaining flanges were machined [7]. (Fig. 3)

Fig. 3:Multiple grooving strategy for roughing process [7]

Manufacturing Engineering

The third strategy (Plunging strategy) is similar to external turning. Groove is produced by tool penetration in the workpiece and consequently axial movement. This process continues until reaching the desired depth of machining. The vital thing that should be considered is the depth of the cut. As grooving inserts are not applicable for external turning, the lower depth of the cut should be applied. Also, it is recommended to stop the axial movement before reaching the groove shoulders. (Fig. 4)


Manufacturing Engineering

Fig. 4: Plunging strategy for roughing process[6, 8]

To achieve finishing dimensions, a 4-step strategy was applied. At first, the desired depth was machined. secondly, the grooving insert moves along the shoulder and goes toward another shoulder. then tool retracts back and moves along another shoulder (Fig. 5)

Manufacturing Engineering

Fig. 5: Finishing process a) first step b) second step c) third step d) fourth step[8]


Generally, insert breakage lead to tool damage[9, 10]. For improving machining results, the tool path was corrected firstly, then machining parameters (ap, Vc, f) were optimized and the shape of the chips was studied regard to feed rate range. These solutions lead to improved tool life, better machining quality, and preventing cutting tool holders from damage through insert breakage.

Research Method and Assumptions

In this study, the SCM420H was used as a workpiece material with 180-210 BHN hardness. which was forged and annealed. There was an oxidation layer on a workpiece surface due to the forging and annealing process which was performed on workpiece material that leads to surface hardening. Fig. 6 shows the workpiece drawing before and after machining process.

Manufacturing Engineering

Fig. 6: Workpiece drawing a) before machining process b) after machining process

As shown in Fig. 7, a groove with 9mm width and 5mm depth was machined on the workpieces by performing two different steps, roughing and finishing. The roughing process was applied by a strategy which was shown in Fig. 8a. This includes 3 steps which were performed from right to left respectively. Each step has 3mm width and 5mm depth. For the finishing process, as shown in Fig. 8b, the grooving tool moves along the shoulder and wall of the groove and retract back respectively.

Manufacturing Engineering

Fig. 7: Workpiece a) before grooving b) after grooving

Manufacturing Engineering

Fig. 8: Workpiece machining strategy a) roughing[8] b) finishing[11]

Fig. 9 shows the clamping system of the workpiece which would benefit from three special jaws for proper clamping of the workpiece.

Manufacturing Engineering

Fig. 9: Workpiece clamping system


In this study, the insert and tool holder were Mitsubishi products. The insert for grooving is GY2M0300F020N-MM MY5015 with 3mm width which was mounted on the Monoblock tool holder GYQL 2020K00-F06 as shown in Fig. 10.

Manufacturing Engineering

Fig. 10: Grooving holder and insert[11]

Machining setup was done and cutting parameters - ap=5, Vc=330, fn=0.05 – adjusted. During the test, 650 pieces of workpiece were machined by the first cutting edge. After 500 pieces of workpiece machining by the second cutting edge, the insert broke and the holder damaged as shown in Fig. 11.

Manufacturing Engineering

Fig. 11: broken insert and holder

To solve this problem, the metallurgical and mechanical properties of the broken holder were checked to assured that there was no matter in the holder manufacturing process. Besides that, the machining strategy was improved by changing the tool path (multiple grooving for roughing[1]) as shown in Fig. 12. Symmetrical machining steps led to equal contact of the grooving insert’s shoulders and reduction in the grater component (Fp) of machining forces (Fp as a radial component and Fc as a tangential component). This results in a lower amount of vibration and consequently improved tool life[12].

Manufacturing Engineering

Fig. 12: Machining strategy for improving rough process [5]

Also, for the finishing process, a strategy like the one which was shown in Fig. 13 was used. This strategy makes it possible to machine the groove shoulder perfectly [5].

Manufacturing Engineering

Fig. 13: Schematic view of suggestion strategy for finishing[11]

In case the grooving tool moves in a radial direction, the radial component of machining force is dominant and others can be ignored. So, by increasing cutting speed, no change occurred in chip formation. But the possibility of tool wear will be increased[1]. Therefore, cutting speed reduced from 330 m/min in both roughing and finishing process to 240 m/min in roughing and 250 m/min in the finishing process. Also, the feed rate was increased from 0.05 mm/rev to 0.16 mm/rev to better chip breaking conditions.

Results and Discussion

As explained above, the broken holders were first tested for hardness and metallurgical properties (spectrometry test). The mentioned experiments were performed by Razi Metallurgical Laboratory, the results of which are as follows.

As a result, both grooving holders have the same alloy elements. Consequently, the hardness test was applied and the same hardness value (45 Rc ) was obtained.

Table 1: Spectrometry test result for a) ordinary holder b) breakage holder

Manufacturing Engineering

Table 2: Hardness test result for a) ordinary holder b) breakage holder

Manufacturing Engineering

According to the hardness and spectrometry test, it is shown that both holders have the same metallurgical properties. So, the machining strategy should be optimized. Fig.14 shows the chip which was obtained by a previous machining strategy that is not a proper chip shape.

Manufacturing Engineering

Fig. 14: Chip which was produced by the previous strategy

Cutting data due to tool breakage shown in Table 3 and related tool life shown in Table 4.

Manufacturing Engineering

Manufacturing Engineering

The optimization progress was performed by cutting data correction according to tool supplier suggestion which is shown in Table 5.

Manufacturing Engineering

Figure 15a shows the chip deformation regard to a feed rate of 0.1 mm/rev. It is known that the chip formation improved after the changes in the machining parameters of the process. However, since the chips were long and did not break, the feed rate increased in four steps until it was finally crushed at 0.16 mm/rev., Figure 15b shows the final chip formation. In addition, in the tests using improper coolant flushing, the chips were not broken but were successfully evacuated from the groove[13]. The insert wear was considered by flank wear which led to poor insert lifetime. When adding high-pressure coolant to the flank face, the chip broke successfully, and correspondingly the tool life increased meaningfully.

Manufacturing Engineering

After the corrections, the process was performed under constant conditions and the test was continued with 4 inserts without damaging the holder. The related data are shown in Table 6.

Manufacturing Engineering

According to the test result, it was suggested to change insert cutting edge per 600 workpiece machining to prevent excessive insert wear which may lead to tool breakage.

Concluding remarks:

In this paper, grooving insert breakage and tool holder damaged were studied. According to experimental test,
It was shown that tool life enhanced through tool path strategy improvement and cutting data optimization. The former was performed by using multiple grooving strategy and the latter was done by adjusting the machining parameters (Vc, ap, fn). At last but not least, the chips were broken successfully by excessive feed rate and using proper coolant flood.


[1] A. Kurt and S. Bakir, "Theoretical analysis and mathematical modeling of deformation and stresses of the grooving tool," Neural Computing and Applications, pp. 1-20, 2019.

[2] Catalogue and Technical guide 2015 Turning, 2015.

[3] T. Zlamal, S. Malotova, T. Szotkowski, R. Cep, and I. D. Marinescu, "The geometry of grooving tool and its influence on dynamic load system for turning," Transportation Research Procedia, vol. 40, pp. 602-609, 2019.

[4] A. A. Farid, "The effect of chip breaker geometry on chip shape, bending moment, and cutting force: FE analysis and experimental study," The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 2014.

[5] Mitsubishi, "Turning Tools Grooving and Cutting Off," Mitsubishi catalogue, 2020.

[6] K. Shahrezaei, "Software development from theory to practical machining techniques," MSc, Department of Engineering Sciences and Mathematics, Luleå University of Technology, 2020.

[7] Walter general catalogue 2018, 2018.

[8] S. Coromant. External grooving [Online] Available:

[9] R. Nicholas, "Tool holder assembly," ed: Google Patents, 2011.

[10] G. Jansson, "Face grooving tool body for metal cutting," ed: Google Patents, 2020.

[11] Turning tools/Rotating tools/Tooling solution MITSUBISHI, Your Global craftsman studio, JAPON, 2017.

[12] J. Saffury, "Chatter suppression of external grooving tools," Procedia CIRP, vol. 58, pp. 216-221, 2017.

[13] K. Sørby and K. Tønnessen, "High-pressure cooling of face-grooving operations in Ti6Al4V," Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part B: Journal of Engineering Manufacture, vol. 220, no. 10, pp. 1621-1627, 2006.

 The future of chemical and petrochemical manufacturing

The future of chemical and petrochemical manufacturing


The chemicals and petrochemical industry in the UK has been one of the successes of the twentieth century. The early success was the result of a growing home market for new products such as plastics and later came further success with the discovery of North Sea oil. This resulted in substantial capital investment and the creation of many jobs in both the direct and support industries.

Cutting through cobalt chrome

Cutting through cobalt chrome

Manufacturers in the orthopedic and dental implant sectors are familiar with difficult-to-machine materials like cobalt chrome. These superalloys are known for their biocompatibility, making them a great choice for medical device manufacturing.

 Top 10 largest Steel Producing Countries in the World

Top 10 largest Steel Producing Countries in the World

The world produced and consumed close to 1,535 million metric tons of crude steel in the year 2015. Emerging economies are quickly climbing the production graph, with some of them having as much as 50% share in gross production of crude steel.


TAP TOOLS Co. has started its activity of importing and supplying machining tools (turning and milling) since 2016 and has gained the representation of well-known companies such as Mitsubishi (Japan Mitsubishi), (UTILIS) of Switzerland, (TBT) of Germany.

Contact Us

Address: Second Floor, No. 16, Fathalikhani Alley, Nemati Alley, Imam Khomeini Street after Ebne- Sina Hospital, Tehran, Iran

Phone: 0098-2162038